Might The Tampa Bay Rays Sign Jamey Carroll?

Anthony Gruppuso-USA TODAY Sports

With the signing of James Loney, the Rays have essentially solidified their starting lineup for the 2014 season. The focus from here will be to find a few quality role players to compliment their roster in the remaining offseason. The Rays appear to be interested in back up infielders, and one of them is Jamey Carroll.

The main reason the Rays have shown interest in Carroll is because of his versatility. Carroll is the prototypical utility player with experience at second base, shortstop, third base and at both corner outfield positions. He has also shown the ability to be a good defender at all of these positions over the course of his career. He even pitched a game for the first time in 2013, hitting 80 MPH as he tossed a perfect inning. The Rays would most likely use him as a backup infielder but his ability to play the outfield as well could prove to be very useful.

Offensively, Carroll is coming off of his worst year at the plate, hitting to a putrid .211/.266/.251 line, but after a year like that, he has nowhere to go but up. He generally has posted good offensive seasons as evidenced by his career line of .272/.349/.338, including .280/.357/.337 line the last five years. Carroll won’t offer any power but does not strike out much. His K% rate of 15.7 was still fairly good in an otherwise dismal season, although his 6.8% walk rate was his lowest since 2002. On the basepaths, he is considered a strong baserunner but does not do much in the way of stealing bases, swiping just 2 bags in 2013. But the most important thing that Carroll does may be his ability to hit leftt-handed pitching.

Carroll’s overall line was terrible, but that primarily came from his numbers against righty pitching–just .193/.247/.217. Against lefties, he was still decent at .258/.315/.333, and there is hope he can trend back towards his .292/.365/.369 career line against them. Carroll’s versatility is nice, and his ability to hit lefties creates an opening for him to get his at-bats. Carroll could spell Matt Joyce, David DeJesus, and occasionally James Loney as well, and the Rays could allow him to stay primarily at his most comfortable defensive position, second base, by moving Ben Zobrist around. Even after a terrible year, don’t disregard Carroll completely at the plate.

Combining his strong defense and versatility with his solid bat against lefties makes Carroll a near-perfect fit for the Rays in a backup role. He will be 40 years old on Opening Day next year, and that along with his dismal 2013 season should guarantee his salary for next season stays low, exactly what the Rays like. If the Rays do indeed sign Carroll, they will get the most out of the ability he has left and he could prove to be a very good asset for them in 2014.

Topics: Jamey Carroll, Tampa Bay Rays

Want more from Rays Colored Glasses?  
Subscribe to FanSided Daily for your morning fix. Enter your email and stay in the know.
  • phattitudes

    You hear his name tossed around a lot; seems like one of those prudent Rays choices. However he is a known quantity and any days he is in the lineup, it will be weaker. The defense is reputed to be solid and the Rays value that. Personally I would like to see the Rays give a shot to Belnome who was with Durham last year, He is not the defender Carroll is, but he has been a solid left handed bat with a .300/.408/.446 line. His 5 year OPS in the minors is .889. He is relatively balanced against left and right handed pitching. He has played 1st, 2nd, and 3rd base defensively. With Zobrist and Rodriquez we already have two versatile defenders. Belnome could be an interesting add. He’s got sufficient versatility and provides an offensive boost as a platoon player or pinch hitter. So while Carroll is a safe choice, I am hoping the Rays give Belnome a shot in spring training. Obviously he would have to earn it but he deserves a chance.

    • Robbie_Knopf

      The issue with Belnome is really his defense–he can’t play shortstop at all and is poor basically everywhere. And at the plate, he has played well, but most of his success comes from good patience, but major league pitchers will throw him more strikes knowing he’s not that scary of a hitter thanks to little power. He’s good depth, but he is a Quad-A player until he proves otherwise. He will get his chance, but that will not be at the beginning of the year.