After acquiring Gavin Lux from the Reds, the Rays have finally filled one of their most important roster vacancies. Now, the biggest sore spot is clearly at the catcher position. Both MLB-level Rays catchers combined for a 0.2 WAR last season with Rays probable starter Hunter Feduccia producing a 0.5 WAR. Therefore, trading for a catcher could be the Rays' best bet at improving at this essential position. Potentially, another deal with the Reds is in the works.
Rays should trade for Reds catcher Tyler Stephenson
Drafted in the first round of the 2015 draft by the Cincinnati Reds, Tyler Stephenson has been a solid contributor in the organization since his arrival. The Georgia native sped through the minor league ranks as he hit a consistent .261 over four seasons. Stephenson received his MLB call-up during the shortened 2020 campaign. The 6'3 backstop only stepped to the plate 20 times, but he displayed his impressive abilities in that small sample size. The right-handed slugger produced a .294 AVG with two home runs showing the Reds front office that they may have their catcher of the future.
So, why would they deal their offensive threat behind the plate? Well, his value isn't at its highest and the market for catchers is always pretty scarce. Therefore, the Reds could deal Stephenson for some other positions of need like relief pitching or outfield depth.
Secondly, the Cincinnati backups behind the dish can hold their own defensively and offensively. Former Yankees catcher Jose Trevino was dealt to the Reds a season ago. Although he struggled in 93 games, Trevino has a track record of success in the stressful confounds of New York. As a member of the Yankees, the Texas native collected a Platinum Glove and an All-Star appearance in 2022. Trevino hit .248 with 11 home runs and fantastic defense to the tune of an AL leading 33.3% caught stealing percentage.
Their third string catcher is former Ray Ben Rortvedt. Despite his tenure with Tampa Bay ending in ruin, Rortvedt put together a solid 2024 with the Rays as he finished with 31 RBIs in 112 games behind the plate. Therefore, the Reds can afford to let one of their talented catchers go in order to add depth at other positions.
